Grammatically Speaking
Tuesday, July 13, 2010 at 11:58AM Remember that post last week about math being the necessary evil? Well, maybe I misspoke! I think Grammar is the necessary evil. Not really, but I did have a very hard time choosing a grammar program for this year. Since this is our first FULL year of homeschooling I don't have a huge pool of experience to draw from when it comes to what works well with my children and what doesn't.
First Language Lessons for the Well Trained Mind (Volumes 1 & 2) is what I chose for GMan. A veteran homeschooler friend of mine recommended it and after looking through hers I know it's something he will like. There is a short, scripted lesson each day, and I love the emphasis on memorizing poetry as you go along. I also really like the fact that it's nongraded, and we can work at our own pace through the book. I also found these printables, done by another homeschooling mom, and have printed and laminated them for our school year. (If you get a chance to poke around her site, it is WELL WORTH your time. This gal is amazing!)
Now, for Miss B we used a simple third grade grammar text last year. I really didn't like it, although she DID. It was quick and didn't require much of her - presented a rule and then she did a couple of worksheets about it, but I found that as I quiz her about it this summer she didn't retain much, so we need a grammar program that teaches and reviews constantly. Enter Grade 4 Daily Grams. I see us doing this at the beginning of each morning. This is what the publisher has to say:
"Concepts are reviewed within 25-30 days, helping students to retain and consistently remember 'older' concepts. Daily Grams format follows the same pattern of capitalization, punctuation, general concepts and sentence combining along with a dictionary review."
Now, doesn't that sound like what I'm looking for? The Daily Grams also go along with the Easy Grammar text. I am hoping that this gives us a more focused approached to grammar with Miss B this year. Since she had gone to public school for the first 3 1/2 years, her view of learning is much different than my son's -- she doesn't think learning is taking place unless mom is standing at the board teaching and assigning pages in a workbook. I am having to ease her out of this gently. So, a more nebulous grammar program like Simply Grammar (which I actually have a copy of and several people have recommended) wouldn't work as well with her. Maybe next year?
If you have a grammar text or approach that has really worked with your children, can you share it with me?? I'm open to lots of help on this one!
Blogger Templates
Reader Comments (2)
Mary ~
Thanks for the link. :) I'm working on the level 3 printables for First Language Lessons now. :)
First Lnguage Lessons is what I used with Kayla... It is GREAT! She retained everything, and to this day can list off the prepostitions, etc. I used Easy Grammar with Emmy last year... it was OK.